Alan Pao's Toxic is a pack punching, visually stylished yet highly unoriginal thriller that is nonetheless an enjoyable way to spend a rainy evening, even if it somewhat fails in delivering the main catch of the plot. Instead we are treated some slightly bizarre looking violence and (undeniably beautiful) half-naked women, but in both cases you can somehow feel that the director didn't go as far as it would have been necessary to show the dark side of the story and how hard it is to tell what is real in this abyss.
When a movie wants to mix a mind-boggling mystery, some half-serious shoot-em-up hit-man-action, the dirty businesses of the underworld, couple of spooks in the footsteps of the Japanese horror movies, some truly Lynchian imagery and a surprisingly effective psychological thriller, you might expect a mess. Luckily, Toxic never really falls apart or stumbles in this aspect. The narrative is semi-incoherent, jumping between times and places, but once you get the different levels, it's simple to follow. Maybe even too simple.
It's a shame that the style-over-substance approach in shooting and editing is mostly there to please the MTV-generation. The crazy camera, hostile towards epileptics, is mostly out of place - even as the madness of the character(s) is slowly revealed and reality is played with, it never feels appropriate, more like a camera that would work in a movie about drug-induced hallucinations. The main actors are mostly nobodies and it shows: they don't get how multilayered their characters are or how to show it. Sizemore doesn't get it either, but he's a good thug, has always been. Swain is underused, and the tragedy of her character never really has time to touch you. The rest, including Danny Trejo, Bai Ling and Costas Mandylor, play their regular roles. You know, the ones they always do. Routine.
The biggest problem, however, is the fact that there is nothing here that hasn't been done better somewhere else. In some cases, to death. So it becomes trite. Even the twist-you-didn't-see-comin' is only a slightly altered version of some of the classic twists combined. But it IS done well enough, it IS mostly logical and you don't feel like you've been cheated (like I felt after I saw 'The Sixth Sense' the second time). Little things along the way start making sense. You might actually consider watching it again, to catch all the hints. But you probably won't, because let's face it, the trip just wasn't that interesting.