Jaques Tati is a modern-day take of Charlie Chaplin; not a heavy talker, interacts in humorous ways to characters and different settings, and overall puts more emphasis on physical humor and the sounds that accompany them. Unlike Chaplin however, he puts almost all his focus on sounds, and is among the first directors to attempt to mesh it with the musical soundtrack that follows. With this movie, he doesn't perfect his skill in the least bit, but it's the beginning of something special between Tati and the camera. His facial expressions and mannerisms are fit for a movie screen, but he just totally lacks the talent to create a coherent story and plot line.
Les Vacances de Monsieur Hulot is about Tati's character taking a vacation and eventually creating chaos amongst the environment around him. That's pretty much about it, the rest of the movie focuses on the pratfalls and gags created by Tati. They are hit-and-miss, but like in a old-school Napoleon Dynamite style, they totally fail to enhance the story or move the plot along; resulting in the audience being at a standstill. What makes this in the least bit superior to Napoleon is that the setting is a character, and one that's actually desirable. Instead of the dull, boring, lifeless Montana, we have the beachside, which provides beautiful cinematography and relaxing scenery.
Tati's advantage over Chaplin is that he has the beautiful Europe to draw influence from. Tai enjoys creating a deep setting that the audience can just step into with no trouble at all, and he accomplishes this easily within the first five minutes; a craft he perfects with his later films like Playtime and Mon Oncle. Mon Oncle would be him at his peak; as he combined great visuals with great music, decent sounds, good acting, and a fun little story that actually keeps the audience interested.
The biggest issue I have with Tati is his inability to move the story and stretching his films as long as possible. Most of his movies can be 30-minute short films easily, but he chooses to continue stretching, stretching, throwing long shots, repetitive gags, and boring boring moments that suck away at your life and overall the quality of the film. Like almost all his movies, this one relies on short, ADD-like gags that are all visual and lack edge, lack intelligence. They don't say much about the characters, they are more like pawns in a chess game being moved around to make something funny. You could replace any person with any celebrity or historical figure and the results are remotely the same; there are no personality clashes, it's just people running into people and doing things to other people accidentally or not by accident. Kind of like what Sex and the City does to New York, the setting and atmosphere becomes a character itself and interacts with everyone.
Bottom Line: Tati is good at making eye candy, but a sugar-coated piece of trash is still a piece of trash, no matter what you do with it, no matter how much you sprinkle. This movie doesn't entertain, doesn't really change the way you see movies; actually doesn't accomplish anything except prove that Tati knows how to manipulate space and
and
and
wait..that's it. There's not much more to say about this movie except
avoid. Avoid. He knows how to incorporate sound, but what good will that do if you have a stupid story to tell?