"Nickelodeon" is the heartfelt tribute by filmmaker Peter Bogdanovich to the earliest days of movie-making, in the first dozen or so years of the 20th century. Apparently a stickler for accuracy, that does show in the script credited to both Bogdanovich and W.D. Richter. It's based on recollections of vintage directors such as Raoul Walsh ("The Big Trail", "Sadie Thompson") and Allan Dwan ("A Broken Doll", "The Forbidden Thing"), and it's a pretty colourful and often delightful look at the filmmaking process of over a century ago.
The film begins by telling us that this was a time when big-shot producers would go out of their way to prevent independents from having ANY success. Its story begins in 1910 Chicago, when attorney Leo Harrigan (Ryan O'Neal) bumbles his way into a screenwriting gig for larger-than-life character H.H. Cobb (a hilarious Brian Keith). Eventually, he's roped into directing. Burt Reynolds plays Buck Greenway, a charming Floridian who comes to NYC and somehow manages to become a movie star. Lovely Jane Hitchcock plays the starlet who comes between them.
"Nickelodeon" is not one of Bogdanovichs' most renowned films; in its time, it was an expensive flop. Part of the problem is that it's going to be far too silly for some viewers, that it goes TOO heavy on the old-style slapstick. It also probably could have used some tightening, as it DOES lose steam as it goes along. But there's still a fair amount to enjoy here. Bogdanovichs' obvious devotion to this period in film history is rather infectious, and the recreations of the era are well done. The stunts are likewise quite impressive.
The main reason that this picture is able to sustain itself for just over two hours is that the cast is so great. O'Neal, Reynolds, and lovely Hitchcock do set off some sparks as their love triangle plays out. Keith steals all of his scenes, as does O'Neals' precocious, Oscar-winning daughter Tatum, who shines in her big negotiation scene. Stella Stevens and John Ritter provide likeable support as an actress and cameraman, and there are MANY familiar faces in character roles, including Harry Carey, Jr., James Best, Brion James, Priscilla Pointer, Don Calfa, Philip Bruns, George Gaynes, M. Emmet Walsh, and Hamilton Camp. You also get to see Lorenzo Music (voice of "Carlton, your doorman" and Garfield the Cat) in an actual on-screen bit, as one of Cobbs' writers.
Some viewers may argue that the subject deserves a more clear-headed, less self-indulgent treatment, and certainly "Nickelodeon" does suffer from some excess. But this viewer personally found it rather charming, and it does create some interesting characters who are worth following from beginning to end.
Also available in a black & white "director's cut" running approximately three minutes longer.
Eight out of 10.